The Pennsylvania Attorney General's Office has reaffirmed the 2011 death of Ellen Greenberg as a suicide.
According to CBS News, a comprehensive review by the state's Attorney General’s Office concluded that Ellen's death, despite new evidence from her family, remains a self-inflicted act.
The Pennsylvania Attorney General's Office, led by Josh Shapiro, is closing Ellen Greenberg's case, reaffirming the death as a suicide after a review between December 2021 and January this year. This decision was communicated to Greenberg's parents' attorney in a recent letter.
Ellen Greenberg, a teacher in Philadelphia, was discovered deceased, with nearly 20 stab wounds, in her Manayunk apartment in 2011. Her tragic death was initially classified as a suicide by the medical examiner. The family, however, has consistently contested this characterization, believing it to be a homicide.
The Attorney General's Office conducted another review of the case between December 2021 and January of this year. This was in response to new findings from Joseph Podraza, the family's attorney.
The new evidence included a detailed deposition from Lyndsey Emery, a neuropathologist, who reexamined Ellen's spinal tissue and found no signs of hemorrhage.
Despite these new findings, the state's top prosecutor has maintained the original ruling and closed the case once more. The decision has not been well-received by Ellen’s parents, Sandra and Josh Greenberg, who have vocally disputed the conclusion. "I'm completely disgusted," said Sandra Greenberg. Her husband, Josh, added, "I think this is a vicious homicide."
Podraza, representing the Greenberg family, has been adamant in his opposition to the suicide ruling. He argued, "This cannot be suicide," pointing to Emery's findings that a lack of hemorrhage is significant. He further emphasized his disbelief by noting, "You don't stab yourself when you're dead." The family's persistent belief in a different manner of death has fueled their ongoing legal battle.
The Greenbergs are pursuing a lawsuit against Philadelphia. Their goal is to have Ellen's death reclassified from suicide to either homicide or undetermined. This legal avenue represents their last hope of seeking justice for their daughter.
Behind the clinical details and legal language lies a family's heartache and unwavering quest for what they deem the truth. The Greenbergs' sustained efforts underline the emotional weight they carry. "These people disappointed me," Josh Greenberg said, reflecting the deep sense of betrayal felt by the family.
Sandra Greenberg expressed her disbelief over the Attorney General’s decision-making process. "I just can't believe what's coming out of the office of a person that's trying to run for governor," she stated, highlighting the political dimension that she feels is implicated in this case.
Ellen’s case continues to generate discussions and raise questions about investigative processes and the ability of new evidence to influence legal outcomes. While the Attorney General’s Office stands firm on its findings, the Greenbergs' fight is far from over.
In conclusion, the Pennsylvania Attorney General’s Office has reaffirmed its ruling of Ellen Greenberg's 2011 death as a suicide after a thorough review. New evidence from the Greenberg family's attorney was insufficient to alter this determination. Ellen’s parents, Sandra and Josh Greenberg, remain steadfast in their belief that their daughter was a victim of a homicide and are pursuing legal actions to challenge the current ruling.
