Written by Ashton Snyder on
 June 12, 2025

Weinstein convicted on one count in New York sex crimes retrial

Harvey Weinstein, the disgraced film producer, has been found guilty on one count of criminal sexual act in the first degree in his New York retrial. The verdict comes after nearly a week of tense deliberations that almost led to a mistrial due to conflicts among jurors.

According to The Guardian, Weinstein was convicted of sexually assaulting Miriam Haley but acquitted on a charge involving Kaja Sokola. The jury remains deadlocked on a third charge involving Jessica Mann, with the judge instructing them to continue deliberations.

The partial verdict represents a significant moment in Weinstein's legal saga, which has included multiple trials across different jurisdictions. This retrial came after his original 2020 New York conviction, which resulted in a 23-year sentence, was overturned on appeal.

Courtroom Tensions Flare

Before the verdict was announced, Weinstein himself addressed the court in a dramatic plea for a mistrial, citing reports of hostility among jurors. The 72-year-old producer, who attended proceedings in a wheelchair while undergoing treatment for leukemia, appeared distressed.

"This is my life that's on the line," Weinstein told Judge Curtis Farber. "I am not getting a fair trial. You are endangering me, Your Honor."

The jury deliberations had been notably contentious, with the foreperson requesting to speak privately with the judge about a troubling situation. The juror reportedly expressed concerns after another panelist made comments that could be interpreted as threatening, saying "I'll meet you outside one day" amid "yelling and screaming."

Accusers Respond To Verdict

Miriam Haley, the production assistant whose testimony led to Weinstein's conviction, expressed hope following the verdict. She highlighted the broader implications of the case for sexual assault survivors.

"Hope that there is new awareness around sexual violence and that the myth of the perfect victim is fading. I hope that this result empowers others to speak out and seek justice," Haley stated after the verdict.

Kaja Sokola, despite the acquittal on charges related to her allegations, called the outcome "a big win for everyone" and expressed hope that her testimony would encourage others to come forward. Meanwhile, Jessica Mann, whose rape allegation remains under deliberation, released a statement defending her testimony.

"I would never lie about rape or use something so traumatic to hurt someone. Rape can happen in relationships – and in dynamics where power and manipulation control the narrative," Mann stated, also accusing Weinstein's legal team of conducting a smear campaign against her.

#MeToo Movement Legacy

The retrial has been viewed as a test of the enduring impact of the #MeToo movement, which Weinstein's original case helped propel into the mainstream. The movement's visibility has diminished in recent years as other social justice causes gained prominence.

Throughout the three-week trial, Weinstein maintained his innocence, with his defense team arguing that all interactions with his accusers were consensual. His attorney, Arthur Aidala, characterized the relationships as "mutually beneficial," suggesting the women received auditions and other professional opportunities.

The defense strategy included testimony from friends of Sokola and Mann who claimed neither woman had contemporaneously reported being assaulted. Prosecutors countered that Weinstein had exploited his industry power to lure women with career promises before sexually assaulting them.

Legal Saga Continues

Weinstein now faces complex legal challenges following this mixed verdict in New York. The former Hollywood powerhouse was previously sentenced to 16 years in prison in California on separate sexual assault charges, a conviction that remains in place. The jury's continued deliberation on the Mann allegation leaves one aspect of the case unresolved. Mann testified during the trial that she never reported Weinstein's assault at the time because she feared she wouldn't be believed and was concerned about potential retaliation.

Weinstein's legal team had repeatedly sought a mistrial during deliberations, pointing to the reported tensions among jurors as evidence of a flawed process. The partial verdict marks another chapter in a legal battle that has become emblematic of accountability efforts for powerful men accused of sexual misconduct.

Author Image

About Ashton Snyder

Independent conservative news without a leftist agenda.
© 2025 - American Tribune - All rights reserved
Privacy Policy
magnifier